Black, Tarry Stools

What Causes Black Tarry Stools?

Black tarry stools can have various causes, ranging in severity from 'needs attention' to 'life-threatening'.  Finding the true cause means ruling out or confirming each possibility – in other words, diagnosis.

Diagnose your symptoms now!
  • see your health summarized and in detail
  • learn what you should be doing right now
  • have a doctor review your case (optional)

Diagnosis is usually a complex process due to the sheer number of possible causes and related symptoms.  In order to diagnose black tarry stools, we could:

  • Research the topic
  • Find a doctor with the time
  • Use a diagnostic computer system.
The process is the same, whichever method is used.

Step 1: List all Possible Causes

We begin by identifying the disease conditions which have "black tarry stools" as a symptom.  Here are four possibilities:
  • Carcinoid Cancer
  • Gastrointestinal Bleeding
  • Possible Urgent Medical Need
  • Stomach Ulcers

Step 2: Build a Symptom Checklist

We then identify all possible symptoms and risk factors of each possible cause, and check the ones that apply:
severe left iliac pain
frequent aspirin use
attempting suicide
trace amounts of occult blood
frequent red blood in stools
major unexplained weight loss
occasional unexplained vomiting
significant right iliac pain
high coffee consumption
severe right lumbar pain
significant abdominal pain
chest pain when breathing
... and more than 30 others

Step 3: Rule Out or Confirm each Possible Cause

A differential diagnosis of your symptoms and risk factors finds the likely cause of black tarry stools:
Cause Probability Status
Gastrointestinal Bleeding 99% Confirm
Carcinoid Cancer 17% Unlikely
Possible Urgent Medical Need 1% Ruled out
Stomach Ulcers 0% Ruled out
* This is a simple example to illustrate the process

Arriving at a Correct Diagnosis

The Analyst™ is our online diagnosis tool that learns all about you through a straightforward process of multi-level questioning, providing diagnosis at the end.

If you indicate irregular stools, The Analyst™ will ask further questions including this one:
Do you ever pass black, tarry stools?
Possible responses:
→ No / don't know
→ Yes, sometimes slightly black/tarry
→ Yes, often slightly black/tarry, sometimes very
→ Yes, my stools are usually/always very black/tarry
Based on your response to this question, which may indicate slightly black/tarry stools, black/tarry stools or very black/tarry stools, The Analyst™ will consider possibilities such as:
A Potentially Urgent Medical Need

Blood, as seen in the stool, can originate anywhere along the intestinal tract.  A black stool (called melena) usually means that the blood is coming from the upper part of the tract.  At least 4 Tablespoons (60ml) of blood must have been lost in order to make the stool black.  Maroon-colored stools suggest that the blood is coming from the middle portion of the intestinal tract, and bright red from the large bowel or rectum.  If stools change color suddenly, it can be evidence of internal bleeding which requires immediate medical attention.

The ingestion of black licorice, Pepto-Bismol, or blueberries can all cause black stools or false melena.  Stools should be tested for the presence of hidden blood.

Carcinoid Cancer

Significant blood in the stool from a carcinoid tumor can cause bowel movements to become black.

Gastric/Peptic/Duodenal Ulcers

Bleeding from an ulcer may occur in the stomach or the duodenum, and sometimes is the only symptom.  Rapid bleeding causes bowel movements to become black or even bloody.

Gastrointestinal Bleeding

Black, tarry stools usually result from bleeding that occurs high up in the digestive tract – for example, in the stomach or first segment of the small intestine (duodenum); blood in the stomach turns black when exposed to stomach acid and enzymes.  A single severe bleeding episode can produce tarry stools for as long as a week, so continuing tarry stools do not necessarily indicate persistent bleeding.

Concerned or curious about your health?  Try The Analyst™
Symptom Entry
Symptom Entry
Full Explanations
Optional Doctor Review
Review (optional)
We use cookies for traffic analysis, advertising, and to provide the best user experience